Carl Counters

Best counters to Carl

Ordered by the low end of each brawler's 95% range against Carl, so a lucky small sample never tops the list.

Brawler	Win rate vs Carl	95% range	vs expected	Games
Shade	63.2%	56–70%	+6.7	174
Amber	59.9%	53–66%	+3.0	207
Gus	59.1%	53–65%	+3.6	232
Nori	59.2%	50–68%	+2.4	120
Griff	52.6%	47–58%	+3.2	291
Rico	51.6%	46–57%	+4.9	320
Ash	54.2%	45–63%	-0.6	107
Wendy	52.8%	45–61%	-5.8	144
Colette	49.4%	43–55%	-0.3	261
Bo	50.7%	42–59%	-2.3	134

"vs expected" is the difference, in percentage points, from what the two brawlers' usual win rates alone would predict. Coloured values are outside the 95% range of chance; grey ones could be noise.

What BrawlPick's draft engine picks into Carl

The picker's own answer when the enemy's only known pick is Carl, on current Ranked maps — before any bans, your team's picks or your collection are taken into account. It weighs map and mode fit, its counter rules, synergy and the observed map statistics, so it can differ from the measured counters above. It is the picker's model, not a measured result.

Maps: the current Ranked maps in the modes where Carl is played most in BrawlPick's data.

Map and mode statistics behind these answers last updated September 19, 2026.

Brawlers Carl beats

The other side of the coin: opponents against whom Carl's team wins most reliably — risky picks once the enemy has shown Carl.

Brawler	Carl's win rate	95% range	vs expected	Games
Edgar	60.1%	54–66%	-0.3	278
Bibi	60.7%	53–68%	+7.5	145
Colt	56.9%	51–62%	+0.6	320
Crow	61%	51–70%	+0.8	105
Mandy	60.4%	51–69%	+10.2	101

About this data

Source:

battle logs from the official Brawl Stars API, collected by BrawlPick. Not copied from another site.

Players:

seeded from BrawlPick users, public leaderboards and top clubs, then widened to the players they met. Likely skewed toward more active, higher-skill players; not a random sample.

Battles:

every 3v3 battle with a win or loss (Ranked and regular matches), each counted once even if seen through several players. These numbers come from battles played Sep 18 – Sep 28, 2026.

Win rate:

share of a brawler's appearances where its team won. Both teams are counted, so the average is about 50%. "Games" is the number of appearances.

Pick rate:

how often a brawler was picked per 100 battles in the same scope. Every battle has six brawlers, so the pick rates of all brawlers add up to about 600%; a brawler on both teams of one battle counts twice.

Battle counts:

unique battles, recovered from the stored pick rates (which share the battle count as denominator): exact only when the rounded rates allow no other number, "≈" when they leave a small range, left out otherwise. "Brawler appearances" counts each of the six brawlers in a battle separately.

Matchups and teammates:

counted from battles in which all six brawlers were identified: a matchup is a game where the two brawlers were on opposite teams, a teammate pair a game on the same team. The "expected" figure combines both brawlers' usual win rates in those battles, so a large difference points to the pairing itself rather than to one brawler being strong overall.

Small samples:

win rates are only shown from 30 games (100 for matchups and teammates); the 95% range shows the remaining uncertainty, and lists are ordered by its low end. That reduces, but does not remove, the chance of a small sample ranking high.

What it cannot tell you:

the range only covers sampling noise. It does not correct for who played a brawler, the drafts it was picked into, the same players appearing in many battles, or balance changes during the collection period.

Game version:

not recorded per battle. If a balance update landed during the collection period, the numbers mix battles from before and after it.

Full methodology: how BrawlPick works.

Related

• Carl stats, best maps and teammates
• Shade stats
• Amber stats
• Gus stats
• How counter-picking works
• All brawlers