Hot Zone · Not in the current Ranked pool

Best Brawlers for Tread Carefully

Which brawler should you pick on Tread Carefully? These are the win rates BrawlPick observed for 99 brawlers on this Hot Zone map, from about 1,993 battles. The most reliable strong performer was Wendy, winning 70.1% of 144 games.

Data last updated September 19, 2026.

Playing Tread Carefully? Open it in BrawlPick

Opens the picker with Hot Zone and Tread Carefully selected. Free, no sign-up needed.

Strongest observed brawlers on Tread Carefully

Ordered by the low end of each brawler's 95% range, not by raw win rate, so a high number from a small sample doesn't jump to the top. The range shows how far the true win rate could plausibly be from the observed one.

#	Brawler	Win rate	95% range	Pick rate	Games
1	Wendy	70.1%	62–77%	7.2%	144*
2	Hank	76.1%	62–86%	2.3%	46*
3	Sirius	68.5%	60–76%	6.4%	127*
4	Ash	68.8%	60–77%	5.5%	109*
5	Juju	68.7%	58–78%	4.2%	83*
6	Amber	62.4%	57–67%	17.8%	354
7	Trunk	69.4%	57–79%	3.1%	62*
8	R-T	70.6%	57–81%	2.6%	51*
9	Chester	65.8%	57–74%	5.6%	111*
10	Draco	68.3%	56–78%	3.2%	63*

* Fewer than 150 games: a limited sample, so the range is wide.

What the data says about Tread Carefully

Tank brawlers are over-represented at the top: 4 of the 10 strongest, against about 1.6 you would expect from their share of the full table.
Assassin brawlers are under-represented: 0 of the 10 strongest, against about 1.9 expected.
The most played brawler here, Tick (450 games), ranks #74 by reliability — popular is not the same as strong on this map.

Classes are the official in-game classes. These are descriptions of the observed games, not causes.

Promising, but not enough games yet

These brawlers won often on Tread Carefully but appear in fewer than 150 observed games, so their win rate is much less certain.

Brawler	Win rate	95% range	Games
Damian	68.4%	55–79%	57*
Kit	65.2%	51–77%	46*
Stu	65.1%	53–76%	63*
Alli	65%	50–78%	40*
Starr Nova	64.6%	55–73%	110*

Most played on Tread Carefully

Brawlers that appeared in the most observed games. Popular is not the same as strong — compare the win rates.

Brawler	Win rate	95% range	Pick rate	Games
Tick	38.4%	34–43%	22.6%	450
Emz	49.4%	45–54%	20.6%	411
Edgar	43.7%	39–49%	18.4%	366
Amber	62.4%	57–67%	17.8%	354
Poco	50%	45–55%	17.4%	346

Lowest observed win rates

Brawlers whose win rate on Tread Carefully was clearly below 50% in this sample, even allowing for its size. This can reflect the map, the drafts they were picked into, or who played them — not necessarily that the brawler can't work here.

Brawler	Win rate	95% range	Games
Brock	28.5%	22–36%	165
Squeak	33%	25–42%	109*
Byron	31.6%	22–43%	76*
Tick	38.4%	34–43%	450
Colt	34.9%	27–43%	132*

All 99 brawlers on Tread Carefully

#	Brawler	Win rate	95% range	Pick rate	Games
1	Wendy	70.1%	62–77%	7.2%	144*
2	Hank	76.1%	62–86%	2.3%	46*
3	Sirius	68.5%	60–76%	6.4%	127*
4	Ash	68.8%	60–77%	5.5%	109*
5	Juju	68.7%	58–78%	4.2%	83*
6	Amber	62.4%	57–67%	17.8%	354
7	Trunk	69.4%	57–79%	3.1%	62*
8	R-T	70.6%	57–81%	2.6%	51*
9	Chester	65.8%	57–74%	5.6%	111*
10	Draco	68.3%	56–78%	3.2%	63*
11	Damian	68.4%	55–79%	2.9%	57*
12	Shade	62.7%	55–69%	8.9%	177
13	Starr Nova	64.6%	55–73%	5.5%	110*
14	Doug	62.9%	54–71%	6.6%	132*
15	Cosmo	61.9%	53–70%	6.7%	134*
16	Gus	59.7%	53–66%	11.3%	226
17	Stu	65.1%	53–76%	3.2%	63*
18	Bo	57.7%	52–63%	15.3%	305
19	Finx	64.5%	52–75%	3.1%	62*
20	Kit	65.2%	51–77%	2.3%	46*
21	Colette	57.8%	51–65%	9.6%	192
22	Nori	57.9%	51–65%	8.9%	178
23	Rosa	59.4%	50–68%	5.3%	106*
24	Lumi	63.8%	50–76%	2.4%	47*
25	Alli	65%	50–78%	2%	40*
26	Chuck	56.2%	49–63%	9.7%	194
27	Meeple	61.3%	49–72%	3.1%	62*
28	Ziggy	64.1%	48–77%	2%	39*
29	Glowy	60.7%	48–72%	3.1%	61*
30	Nita	54.8%	48–61%	10.4%	208
31	Poco	50%	45–55%	17.4%	346
32	Emz	49.4%	45–54%	20.6%	411
33	Bibi	50.7%	44–57%	11.6%	231
34	Pierce	56.3%	44–68%	3.2%	64*
35	Willow	54.7%	43–65%	3.8%	75*
36	Larry & Lawrie	52.9%	43–62%	5.1%	102*
37	Griff	49.1%	43–55%	13.7%	273
38	Penny	48.5%	43–55%	13.3%	264
39	Gigi	56.5%	42–70%	2.3%	46*
40	8-Bit	48.7%	42–55%	11.1%	222
41	El Primo	49%	42–56%	9.8%	196
42	Cordelius	54.7%	41–67%	2.7%	53*
43	Mico	57.6%	41–73%	1.7%	33*
44	Najia	57.6%	41–73%	1.7%	33*
45	Otis	53.6%	41–66%	2.8%	56*
46	Kenji	47.5%	39–56%	6.9%	137*
47	Jacky	50%	39–61%	4%	80*
48	Bolt	53.2%	39–67%	2.4%	47*
49	Surge	45.8%	39–53%	10.6%	212
50	Lou	47.6%	39–56%	6.2%	124*
51	Mortis	46.8%	39–55%	7.1%	141*
52	Bull	47%	39–55%	6.7%	134*
53	Edgar	43.7%	39–49%	18.4%	366
54	Meg	48%	38–58%	5%	100*
55	Max	50%	38–62%	3.4%	68*
56	Kaze	48.8%	38–59%	4.2%	84*
57	Mina	47.9%	38–58%	4.7%	94*
58	Mandy	50.9%	38–64%	2.8%	55*
59	Pam	46.9%	38–56%	5.7%	113*
60	Buzz	48.7%	38–60%	3.7%	74*
61	Spike	45.4%	37–54%	7.1%	141*
62	Pearl	49.2%	37–61%	3.2%	63*
63	Frank	45.1%	37–53%	7.1%	142*
64	Maisie	49.2%	37–62%	3%	59*
65	Tara	46.7%	37–57%	4.5%	90*
66	Dynamike	42.5%	37–49%	13%	259
67	Berry	44.2%	36–52%	7.4%	147*
68	Moe	53.3%	36–70%	1.5%	30*
69	Sam	53.3%	36–70%	1.5%	30*
70	Barley	42.6%	35–50%	8.1%	162
71	Jessie	40.8%	35–47%	12.8%	255
72	Gale	44.6%	35–55%	4.6%	92*
73	Sprout	50%	34–66%	1.8%	36*
74	Tick	38.4%	34–43%	22.6%	450
75	Shelly	41.9%	33–51%	5.9%	117*
76	Fang	41.8%	33–52%	4.9%	98*
77	Eve	45.1%	32–59%	2.6%	51*
78	Ollie	44.2%	32–58%	2.6%	52*
79	Sandy	40.4%	31–50%	5%	99*
80	Charlie	45%	31–60%	2%	40*
81	Rico	38.2%	30–47%	6.8%	136*
82	Bea	42.6%	30–56%	2.7%	54*
83	Grom	40%	30–51%	4%	80*
84	Clancy	39.8%	30–51%	4.2%	83*
85	Crow	36%	29–44%	7.5%	150
86	Carl	38.1%	28–49%	4.2%	84*
87	Belle	42.9%	28–59%	1.8%	35*
88	Colt	34.9%	27–43%	6.6%	132*
89	Leon	38.1%	27–50%	3.2%	63*
90	Melodie	38.2%	27–51%	2.8%	55*
91	Lily	37.5%	25–52%	2.4%	48*
92	Squeak	33%	25–42%	5.5%	109*
93	Janet	38.7%	24–56%	1.6%	31*
94	Buster	34.7%	23–49%	2.5%	49*
95	Darryl	32.4%	23–44%	3.7%	74*
96	Piper	32.4%	22–44%	3.4%	68*
97	Byron	31.6%	22–43%	3.8%	76*
98	Brock	28.5%	22–36%	8.3%	165
99	Mr. P	32.7%	21–47%	2.5%	49*

8 more brawlers were seen on Tread Carefully with fewer than 30 games and are not rated.

How to use these numbers

These are observed results, not a prediction. A win rate also reflects who played the brawler and the drafts it was picked into: a brawler that is usually chosen as a counter will look stronger than it would as a blind first pick.

Use the table to shortlist brawlers for Tread Carefully, then decide from your draft: what was banned, what your team needs and what the enemy picked. That last step is what the BrawlPick picker does for you — it weighs these numbers together with counters, synergy and role balance, so its recommendation is not simply this table sorted by win rate.

About this data

Source:: battle logs from the official Brawl Stars API, collected by BrawlPick. Not copied from another site.
Players:: seeded from BrawlPick users, public leaderboards and top clubs, then widened to the players they met. Likely skewed toward more active, higher-skill players; not a random sample.
Battles:: every 3v3 battle with a win or loss (Ranked and regular matches), each counted once even if seen through several players. Mostly from the days before the update date.
Win rate:: share of a brawler's appearances where its team won. Both teams are counted, so the average is about 50%. "Games" is the number of appearances.
Small samples:: win rates are only shown from 30 games; the 95% range shows the remaining uncertainty, and lists are ordered by its low end.
Game version:: not recorded per battle. If a balance update landed during the collection period, the numbers mix battles from before and after it.

Full methodology: how BrawlPick works.

More Hot Zone maps and guides

Playing Tread Carefully right now?

BrawlPick combines map fit with the live draft — bans, your team, the enemy picks and the brawlers you own — and recommends a brawler with the reasons behind it.

Get a recommendation for this map